Responsibility & Other ‘R’ Words
I don’t watch the news or read any major news media stories. I find them highly spun toward pure editorializing and very agenda driven, much like the propaganda mills of the second world war. I have a bookmarked group of sites I read that specifically report on publishing news and I read them every few days — but that is only because the publishing world is kind of the wild-west right now, and everything is rapidly changing. So, other than the fact that Amazon changed its associates program and Barnes & Noble is closing 20% of its brick and mortar stores, I don’t know anything that is going on in the world.
So, on Facebook, when a friend posted something about blaming a rape victim for being raped due to the clothes she was wearing or how much alcohol she’d consumed, I did not realize that a current event was being discussed. I replied with:
I wouldn’t say it was a reason, because a man chooses his own actions and evil is evil… but I would certainly say that some women could be less at risk consuming less alcohol or dressing differently or being in a different place.
This resulted in a really angry private message and my comment being removed.
It irritated me, but I didn’t pursue it. A few days later, looking at a fellow-writer’s Facebook, I saw a bunch of articles and commentary about some teen football players, rape, and the outcry about the lack of sympathy for the victim. So I’m guessing that the original post days ago that resulted in the angry personal message was about that story. If I’d known it was a current events story, I likely would have ignored the conversation.
But it stayed with me and I ended up talking about it with Gregg — my husband who hates rape with a deep, hot, burning hatred hotter than the heart of the sun.
“Okay, so straw man.” Gregg said, “Let’s say there’s a pit. Odds are there aren’t any dangerous snakes down in the pit. Well, one way to guarantee you never get snake-bit is don’t ever jump into the pit. Teenagers being teenagers — they are going to jump into the pit. Still, even if you get down in the pit, if you are aware of the risks, careful, sober, and dress appropriately, even should you encounter a snake, you have a good chance at being able to handle the situation. Of course, if you decide to get drunk, cover yourself in snake nip, and jump feet first into the pit, in the rare event that there are snakes down there, you are very likely to get bit. Now, your choice to get in the pit drunk covered in snake nip doesn’t excuse the snake for biting you, and the snake still deserves to die. No question. But it also isn’t wrong to say you could have made better choices and you are certainly responsible for YOUR choices.”
The more I talked about it, the more I decided to talk about it with Kaylee. And, the more I talked about it with Kaylee, the more I decided to share this story openly with you today.
When I was 17, I wasn’t a good kid – not by any stretch of the imagination. I kept a good facade, I kept good grades, and I worked a good job, but that was where any goodness in me ended. In fact, I was downright bad – bad enough that seeing my beautiful, good daughter, I lie awake at night afraid sometimes that she’ll make the same mistakes I made, and be as stupid as I was.
Sparing you the details of all of my badness, I will just say that on New Years Eve, 1989, a friend and I made plans to go out. We spent hours at her house getting ready, dressing to the nines in micro-mini skirts, tight, revealing tops, stupidly high heals, and big-hairing it as only teenagers in the 80’s could do. Then we headed to Ft. Benning, Georgia, to a dance club there. Since we were 16 & 17 respectively, we had to use fake ID’s to get into the place. But, they weren’t strict. In fact, my friend used her mother’s and I used a man’s ID to get in. As long as the bouncer could say he saw an ID, he didn’t care. And then we drank. And danced. And drank. Ft. Benning is an infantry post, which means the men in that bar out numbered the women 20-1. Once we paid our initial cover charge, we didn’t have to buy a drink. We had a table full of men just happy as larks to buy them for us.
Sometime around midnight, the bouncer’s brother started hanging out at our table. I wasn’t interested in him on any level, because he wasn’t in the military, and for some reason, I felt safer drinking and partying with the guys in the military. I think because I knew so many people there personally because of my job (I worked at a military supply store), I just felt safe.
This guy didn’t fit in there. His hair was too long, his clothes were too wrong, and his attitude didn’t fit. I blew him off, and I guess he didn’t like it. At some point, somehow, he cornered me and dragged me into an empty room.
And he raped me.
I’ll spare you the horrific details. At some point, he choked me. Years later I realized that I passed out for a space of time. When I could breathe again, I thought he’d kill me, but something stopped him. I had bruises on my neck for days and wore every turtle necked sweater I owned in an attempt to hide them.
I never reported it. I had — what I believed to be with the perceptions and filters of a 17-year-old girl — really good reasons at the time that don’t make sense under the harsh microscope of hindsight. I never told my friend. I never told the Military Police stationed right outside. I never even told my parents until this past weekend before writing this post. Until now, I never really talked about it. I just buried it.
Here’s what I want to say. I knew something then, and I know something now. If I hadn’t been in that bar, dressed the way I was dressed, as drunk as I was, he couldn’t possibly have raped me. While that doesn’t make what he did okay, or excuse him from any of the evil of his act, it is a simple fact and it is a fact worth stating. It is not zero-sum game – taking responsibility on one hand does not remove it from the other hand. I was where I shouldn’t have been and completely ignored any risk, and I got snake-bit.
While I am not responsible for his actions, I am entirely responsible for mine. I bear complete responsibility for myself, and for just how many of my decisions led me to that place. The modern feminist double standard would have you believe that I was not responsible for wearing provocative clothes, getting drunk, and using fake ID to go to a bar where the men outnumbered the women 20 to 1.
That double standard holds women entirely blameless and above the law on the one hand and persecutes and punishes men, deserving or not, forever and ever and always amen. I believe that double standard opens the door to the near complete and total destruction of entirely innocent and undeserving men like in the case of the Duke LaCrosse team. And I absolutely believe that same double standard is also partly to blame for the number of rapes and sexual assaults that occur in our culture every year because that double standard actually has nothing to do with the realities of human nature.
The truth is, that night so many years ago when I was raped probably forged the way for the rest of my senior year in high school and acted as a catalyst for all of the choices I made that resulted in my marriage to my ex-husband. There is no telling what I would have done differently in my life, but honestly, I refuse to devote any emotion or energy into regrets or what-ifs.
Here’s the end and sum of my discussion about this: if some football players raped a girl, then of course they should be prosecuted and punished. The fact that they are 16 and 17 and on the football team should have no bearing. The fact that the girl they raped was drinking and dressed provocatively does not excuse or forgive and should not be seen by anyone as a mitigating factor for the evil of their actions.
But, it can’t stop there. There is more.
There is something to be learned from my story, and countless other stories like mine. I learned my lesson. I was never drunk in a bar again. In fact, I was probably only ever drunk in my life a handful of times after that night, but I was on a path to life long sobriety. And, I became kind of hyper-conscious about how I dressed and, to this day, how my daughter dresses. Because, if I hadn’t have been dressed the way I was dressed, in the place I was in, with as much alcohol in me as I had, then…
Hallee
I’m so grateful for your visit, today.
You would bless me if you added me to your feed reader or subscribed via email.
You can also become a fan on Facebook or follow me on Twitter. I would love to see more of you!
Very honest writing, a post every mother with teenage girls should read and share with their daughters. I will be sharing it with my two.
Thank you, Linda.
Thank you
Thank you.
I made a lot of questionable decisions as a young woman that could have had such worse consequences.Now that I have a 5yo it’s making me think about safety and smarts. It’s okay to have fun, but you can do it and be safe at the same time.
Again, thanks for sharing. That can’t have been easy
It isn’t easy. I’m a much bigger fan of exposing my good choices instead of my bad. But, the Holy Spirit tends to push me toward exposure on all levels, and I’ve learned not to ignore – lol.
Thank you for your openness and honesty. So in agreement with Linda’s comment! I do not have a teenage girl, or even a daughter, but, this is a must read for young ladies everywhere. Not to excuse the actions of the offenders, but young ladies need to be aware of what can happen because of choices they may make. Sadly, even making good choices, women can become victims also. Through your choices back then, you have grown and learned, you have become a woman God is using. May he continue to bless you.
Excellent post, Hallee, and I hope some young women and mothers read it and take heed. I have a similar background/story from my senior year and college. Made stupid decisions. Only by God’s grace did my decisions finally bring me to my knees before the Lord. Then my life changed. For both boys and girls, the world of TV and movies and magazines and advertising leads them to think all these bad choices and illicit behavior is normal. Then they do something, and bam! The system comes down on them and tags them as criminal. Violence and sex is glamorized until it happens in real life and real consequences hit. Moms and Dads, guard your children and pray for their safety and choices. I do believe my parent’s prayers eventually brought me out of my stupidity.
Thank you for sharing your story. I know it must have been hard and emotional for you, but I also hope it will bring a deeper level of healing. I am so sorry that that happened to you. I hope you are surrounded by love and support by those closest to you as you continue to “unstuff.” Thank you for doing that.
While I agree with a lot of what you say, women and girls shouldn’t have to think about dressing to not get raped. Women get raped even if they aren’t drunk and wearing tight clothes.
A man is not a snake. A snake bites because it is an animal working on instinct. A man is a human being and knows the difference between right and wrong. Men who rape aren’t doing so because of ANYTHING the woman did. It was NOT your fault.
I don’t drink, and usually don’t dress an any way that would be considered provocative, so I’m not saying that’s okay. But we live in a culture that seems to think the women have to protect themselves, rather than men not behaving like scum. And the coverage from this incident only furthered that.
We need to teach our sons not to be rapists, that a woman doesn’t owe them anything just because she’s wearing a short skirt and he bought her a drink, rather than teaching our daughters to be afraid of every situation.
MY responsibility for MY choices does NOT mean that I am to BLAME for what happened to me. HE is to blame. I would never imply otherwise.
.
Women get raped in all kinds of situations, and rape is wrong EVERY TIME. Men who rape women should be punished, SEVERELY, every time.
.
But that does NOT mean that girls should not guard their actions and make good choices so that they are at less risk. Period. And, if my experiences teach my daughter to guard herself in social situations, then all the better for her. Because my sharing my experiences just might help her make a GOOD choice one day instead of a BAD choice.
I agree with everything you have said, I hope you didn’t think otherwise. And I applaud you for being so public with something like this, I can’t imagine how hard this was.
I just think it’s important to not forget the other side when we mention how girls need to guard themselves. Most of the coverage of the incident in Steubenville has completely ignored this and it has really been getting to me.
I have nothing profound to add Hallee but love you lady. I agree 100% with what you are saying. Thank you for being brave and sharing yourstory.
Hailee, strength comes in sharing. We decided to share our very personal journey of infertility a long time ago to whomever might need to know it. Sharing your story might encourage 1 mom to share with her daughter. It might cause a reader that was much like 17yo you to change. Be blessed.
Yeah – I didn’t even know how to look up the story to confirm the ages of the teens. I just searched this morning for “rape case” in the news and found the word Steubenville. This morning was the first time I even saw the word. So, I’m coming at this with NO days-long background on this specific story.
.
As the mother of sons, I concur. We must teach our sons to respect women, and to defend them. I think that latter part is important. I would hope that if my sons were at a party and saw a girl at risk, they would do what they had to protect rather than take advantage. And, we’ll teach them that for sure!
There are instances where our choices don’t seem to be a part of what happens, but in most cases they do. Most of all, I wish you had had someone you could talk to about it back then. Carrying that around as a secret had to have affected everything you did or thought about your self and others for decades. Teens make mistakes, and I know that was not the intent of your sharing this today but I hope that kids that make a mistake that results in something that brutal and terrible will talk to a trusted friend or counselor and not carry it around. {{{{{{{{{{{{{{{{Hallee}}}}}}}}}}}}}} And yes, we can choose not to act as walking bait but it still does not absolve the sort of person who initiates a brutal attack on someone they see as “prey.”
You are so right. Not many are brave enough to say what you have said. I like Gregg’s analogy. I can not add anything better than what has already been said.
Of course all men aren’t snakes. But I would feel comfortable characterizing rapists as snakes. Just as all women aren’t hopelessly brainwashed feminists. But some are.
You’re so brave for sharing this, Hallee. God bless you for speaking out! My daughter is just 3 years old, but I work with the youth group at our church and I don’t think they realize the responsibilities that they carry. A great speaker, Lynn Cowell, who I heard once, said that it is up to US as females to guard men’s hearts. We shouldn’t push our cleavage on them. We shouldn’t bring them to the cliff and then get upset when they don’t want to stop. We have a responsibility, knowing how hormonal teenagers and men can be, to NOT challenge them with that temptation. That attention feels really good… until it’s gone further than you ever wanted it to. Thank you again for sharing your story.
Thank you for sharing your story. Although not all young women have been raped, most of our “skeletons” have the same bones: underage drinking, older men, sexy clothing, lying to paremts, and sneaking out. It is a recipe for trouble. Many stories of rape are because we choose to put ourselves in risky situations. We choose to go home with strangers from the bar come closing time. We choose to lie to our parents about our whereabouts after the school dance. We choose to dress a certain way to get a certain attention {there is a fine line between classy and trashy}. We choose to lie about our age to older men. We choose to jog in a dark park alone. We chose to walk to our car alone instead of calling building/campus security to walk us out late at night. These are choices we make as young, naive ladies. A good analogy of the situation is sunscreen…. using sunscreen doesn’t prevent skin cancer, but it certainly helps. Making smart, safe choices doesn’t prevent rape, but it certainly helps. Thank you for speaking out on this subject! It is a painful subject in many of our hearts, but one that young ladies today need to be educated on.
Hallee thank you and I love you unconditionally. I was raped at 15. I was not dressed provacatively in the least. I had just left basketball practice was sweaty and nasty in shortsand a t-shirt and tennis shoes. I saw some friends -yes older- but friends none the less. they asked if I wanted a ride home.. they did not take me home directly they stopped somewhere else first. IT was in that place that my “no” was not taken at face value. Like I said, they were friends, I had hung out with them many times before and never EVER had a problem with them. So, was I wrong for accepting a ride home from what I thought to be friends? how could I, sober, stop 4 17-18 yr old boys from taking what they so obviously wanted? How was that any of my fault? A woman should not fear being raped because she walks to a bathroom in a public place drunk or sober. I think females should dress modestly, but how a woman dresses does not mean she is inviting sexual advances or rape. Before I started being more conservative in my dress I did not think to myself whether or not an outfit would benefit me sexually I dress then as now for what I like and think looks good; now my hems are a little longer and necklines a little higher but still the same principle.
you have written powerful words and i admire and congratulate you in telling your story in such a public medium. my father was in the navy for over 20 yrs. and in charge of a number of young sailors for many years, besides having been one himself. he was consistently telling his four daughters of the dangers out there and the responsibility we had to present ourselves in a way that no one could take it as an invitation. thank you for putting yourself out there today.
p.s. i just finished reading your free e-book, “greater than rubies” and now need to download the trilogy to find out the rest of maxi’s and sarah’s stories.
Of course you weren’t wrong. Rape is never okay, the woman is never at fault.
Hallee, I am not here to comment on your opinion (although I concur with the place/dress argument) or the case at hand. I came to hug your seventeen year old self and thank her for coming forward and sharing so poignantly what you have, such that others may teach their daughters and hopeful give them one more tool in avoiding such at unfortunate situation. Love your God given wisdom Hallee. Shelley
Thank you, my beautiful friend.
Thank you for sharing this. A friend alerted me to your post, and I’m so grateful that they did. You make a valid point. One that SOME victims’ advocates do use in their educating and awareness in how to reduce your risk of becoming a victim of crime…but, of course, there are some who find it offensive and like to use the point that a woman could be inebriated and naked and that still doesn’t give anyone the right to take advantage of her. Well, duh. But, I’d prefer to not be drunk and naked at a party (and I don’t mean Jane Doe, I mean, ME in this scenario), or for my teenaged daughters to be naked and drunk at a party. Or drunk. Or naked. Or in any condition that impairs their judgment, their decision-making, or their defense mechanism. It helps. I think arguing that “No matter what, no one deserves to be raped” (which is true and accurate and honest…but what about ME? Shouldn’t I do things to help myself NOT be a victim as well?) is counterproductive. Of course that’s true…but why not use this as a teachable moment for our children that drinking and drug use is not a good idea. That it leads to substantial impairment/judgment/decision-making in a population of our society that is not yet (generally speaking) mature or rational or aware of consequences when SOBER! I mean, really…you take a group of teenagers who have no supervision/rules/controls and then you add an unlimited supply of alcohol…and bad things are gonna happen.
Like you, I had a less-than-stellar teenage experience. I made bad — BAD — choices becaue I thought I was so mature and responsible and cool…but, as Steubenville has taught us in the last week, that anything I do while “substantially impaired” is not my fault, nor am I able to consent to. So that means when I engaged in any behavior when I was intoxicated as a teen, I was sexually assaulted/raped, whether I knew it or not. That’s not really how I ever viewed it, but that’s what keeps being pounded in my head. Again, I was never in a situation like the one that unfolded in Steubenville, so I’m not saying that what happened to Jane Doe was consensual or was not traumatic and horrible and humiliating and so on. It WAS.
Which brings me to another point that we’ve been “taught” in the aftermath of Steubenville…that no one should feel compassion for anyone but Jane Doe, period. Because doing so is “endorsing rape.” I disagree. I can’t say I feel compassion for Trent Mays, but I do feel compassion for Ma’lik Richmond. When he said “I’m sorry” in court (he said significantly more than that, but it’s hard to hear it), the victim’s mother said, “I know you are, and I forgive you.” So, why isn’t it human or acceptable for anyone in the general public to feel compassion for this boy as well, if the victim’s mother can? Feeling compassion for a human being doesn’t mean negating what they did, nor does it mean it didn’t happen, nor does it mean you DON’T feel compassion for the victim. I’m confused as to why the concept of compassion toward someone who has done wrong — but who people can recognize that there is hope for, that he has a soul — is categorized as such a fault. (I wrote about this issue as well; it’s just a tad longer than this comment!)
But, thank you, for sharing this with us. Big *hugs* to you! :)
I just wanted to offer my love and support. I hope you truly understand and believe that you could have done nothing differently (besides stay or go home) to avoid being raped. Less alcohol, a longer skirt, more wherewithal…none of that would have stopped that sick bastard.
I know we have fundamentally different beliefs on a women’s role in a man’s actions. I’ll leave that debate for another day. XX
You are so brave, Hallee. Thank you so much for telling your story. I had a very similar situation in college (before I met you) and I never really dealt with it until yrs later when I admitted it to myself & went to a counselor. I needed to speak to someone who didn’t know me & love me, like my family & close friends. She made me see that it was NOT my fault, that me being irresponsible (drinking & flirting) was not a license for that jerk to take advantage of me, and that I had to forgive myself for my mistakes and learn from them and work hard to prevent them in the future, which I think I have and I will continue to do every day of my life. When my daughter is a teenager I will share my heartbreak with her too and pray she is smarter & safer than I was. Thank you.
Thank you for sharing your story so openly and honestly. I truly admire your courage! I pray that complete healing has come to your heart and emotions. Blessings to you….
Hallee,
I just wanted to add my words of love, support and encouragement to all of the others. Thank you so much for having the courage to tell your story. I know that it was not easy … not easy to tell your parents, to discuss with your teenage daughter, or to share with all of us. My heart breaks for that 17 year old girl. Even if you had made better / different decisions, that is no guarantee that the outcome would have been different. But your point is well-taken, and one I think needs to be made: choosing not to drink, to dress modestly, or at least to not dress provocatively, not to go where you shouldn’t certainly won’t prevent all rape (in the global sense), but it just might help someone avoid it (on an individual basis). Rape is NEVER the fault of the girl who does make unwise decisions about those things. But if even one young lady is spared that trauma by making those wiser choices you discuss, I fail to see how advocating those choices can be a bad thing or could be construed as suggesting in any way that the rapist is not responsible or that the girl at fault for her own rape.
I hope what I’m trying to say makes sense. Thank you again for telling your story and for encouraging our young ladies to make wise choices. It certainly doesn’t hurt them, and it just might help them avoid a horrible (and criminal!) act.
Blessings,
Michelle